![]() She noted that both the Trump and Biden administrations had taken steps to help student borrowers under a federal law that allows the education secretary, in a national emergency like the pandemic, to "waive or modify any statutory or regulatory provisions" applying to the federal student loan program. "In every respect, the Court today exceeds its proper limited role in our Nation's governance," she wrote. Take Justice Elena Kagan's dissent on the last day of the court term, in which she protested Chief Justice John Roberts' opinion for the six-justice conservative super-majority, throwing out the Biden student loan forgiveness program. But just as upset from time to time are the conservatives, whose dissenting opinions, and even some concurring ones, betray long-held grievances.Īnd then there are the times that a dissent just gets under a justice's skin. Feelings seem raw, certainly for the court's three liberal justices, who were on the losing end of some - but not all - of the court's biggest cases this term. It's hard to imagine that happening at today's Supreme Court. Justice Antonin Scalia once wrote in dissent that if he had written an opinion like the majority's, he "would hide his head in a bag."īut the next night he was dining with the author of the majority opinion, Anthony Kennedy, and other justices he disagreed with. ![]() Supreme Court dissents can be pointed, even acid on occasion.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |